Review Methodology
This page explains the criteria South Report uses to evaluate products. The weight of each criterion varies by category, because what matters in a router is not what matters in a pair of pruners.
What we evaluate
- Performance: how well a product does its core job, based on published specifications and standards.
- Build quality: materials, construction and the parts most likely to wear out.
- Ease of use: setup, controls and day-to-day convenience.
- Features: whether extras solve a real problem or only add cost.
- Maintenance: upkeep, replacement parts and ongoing costs.
- Warranty and support: the length of cover and what it includes.
- Long-term value: what a product costs over its working life, not only on the day you buy it.
- Suitability: who a product is right for, and who should look elsewhere.
Research and testing are different
Unless a guide says otherwise, South Report guides are based on independent research and do not reflect physical testing by us. If a guide includes hands-on experience, it will say so clearly. See our Product Testing Policy.
Why we do not use star ratings
A score implies a level of measurement that research alone cannot support. We use plain statements such as who a product is best for, along with its limitations.