Skip to content
Independent Advice. Smarter Shopping. Better Everyday Choices.

Review Methodology

This page explains the criteria South Report uses to evaluate products. The weight of each criterion varies by category, because what matters in a router is not what matters in a pair of pruners.

What we evaluate

  • Performance: how well a product does its core job, based on published specifications and standards.
  • Build quality: materials, construction and the parts most likely to wear out.
  • Ease of use: setup, controls and day-to-day convenience.
  • Features: whether extras solve a real problem or only add cost.
  • Maintenance: upkeep, replacement parts and ongoing costs.
  • Warranty and support: the length of cover and what it includes.
  • Long-term value: what a product costs over its working life, not only on the day you buy it.
  • Suitability: who a product is right for, and who should look elsewhere.

Research and testing are different

Unless a guide says otherwise, South Report guides are based on independent research and do not reflect physical testing by us. If a guide includes hands-on experience, it will say so clearly. See our Product Testing Policy.

Why we do not use star ratings

A score implies a level of measurement that research alone cannot support. We use plain statements such as who a product is best for, along with its limitations.